Home / Road bikes / Vitus Bikes Zenium Disc – Tiagra 2017 vs Vitus Bikes Zenium VR Disc – 105 2017 Road Bike Comparison. The 2016 Tiagra is pretty nice. But then again, I ride a lot more than my ex, and I always assume 105 is going to outlast Tiagra. With the new Shimano 105 R7000 you get a good range of gears for both the … RS500 is about on par with Tiagra. If money is not a concern, then there's absolutely nothing wrong with buying the best. December 2013 edited December 2013 in Road buying advice. On entry level bikes, a lot of mfgs skimp and go with cheaper brakes, cassette, chain, and crank. I've heard this too. These are wheels that will give you years of reliable rolling performance and are ideal for all-weather cycling. May 9, 2016 at 7:51 pm . Crank - This is the bigger one. They usually put on KMC, which is fine. I just bought a full Tiagra groupset for one of my bikes. I decided my next bike should have at least what he has. cycling, Press J to jump to the feed. Just to add to this, a few years of age is as good as going down a level. It's massivley appreciated and I always manage to learn from you guys! bikes A part from the obvious 10sp vs 11sp is there such a big difference between the two in performance and weight to make a noticeable difference. I know Cannondale is an elite cycling brand but Cube is also a great one. Is the 300g savings really going to make that much difference in your climbs? I have no regrets. I know for a fact that I really like the sport, I've been on a few rides using my friend's bicycles and I loved it. 105 is definitely an upgrade over Tiagra, particularly in the current offering. Shimano Tiagra Vs 105 Vs Ultegra. 0. In fact, it is very hard to distinguish between the new 105 and Ultegra. Geovile. Am I really missing out? Obviously it will be cheaper, but I'm saying much cheaper -- often times they mark 105 bikes up way more than what the actual 105 components cost over Tiagra. Xcountry or MTB benefit more from Disc brakes, as they require the hard stops more often. Both help me go forward ! And the new 105 is almost entirely indistinguishable from Ultegra. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Discussion of everything bicycle related. Many usually end up putting in square taper FSA cranks instead of Shimano hollowtech. I would go with 105 just so you are up to 11 speed like the other higher end groupsets. I'll probably upgrade to Ultegra eventually. The alloy bikes start at $999 (for the Disc Sora) and top out at $1,599 (for the Disc 105 SE). Both are also great brands. The cost difference between Tiagra and 105 is less than the cost difference between 105 and Ultegra. When you are due for chain and cassette replacement switch to ultegra. The Shimano 105 group on this bike is a gem. 2012 Tiagra vs. 2011 105 - advice needed please ASAP. The thing I notice the most was the larger gear spacing on the Tiagra, because that's a 10 speed 11-32 and my 105 is an 11-speed 11-28. Am I really missing out? Very stiff frame, I felt like all my power was going straight to the wheels, not to mention it was the lightest of the two bikes (I loved it). Shimano Tiagra Drivetrain The Shimano Tiagra groupset gets a revamp for 2016 in looks, design and technology. I'd happily go new 105 for a good durable serviceable long life hub. As a beginner cyclist will I tell the difference? In the end you will notice. Here's my question. I Have a 9 y/old pair if Ultegra hubs that given and continue to give excellent service on minimal maintainance. Earning Disclosure. No. Specification. There is a reason people love to run old Campag still. 105 has better shifting and is 11 speed. This will sound completely wrong, but - try electronic! The Synapse Carbon 105 if a fully capable bike that is a very satisfying ride, albeit a bit downsized in frame dimension. ReddIt. A Shimano Tiagra groupset with 28mm wide Continental tyres are equipment highlights. I was about to lobby for Tiagra, because I think it's a very good groupset, but 11 speed vs. 10 speed, and the Shimano bits on the 105 bike (cranks and brakes) make that a winner for the small difference in cost. What am I really missing out on here? If someone dropped a 105 groupset in my lap, I'd install it without question, but I have zero complaints with my current Tiagra setup. To put it bluntly, the benchmarks if you’re riding Shimano (and let’s face it, if you’re a first-timer or buying a budget bike, then you probably are) are Deore for mountain bikes and Tiagra for road bikes. Chain - again ... who cares. But my focus this season are sportive/gran fondo events, so I don't see a problem at this point. If, for example, you can boast a carbon frame hung with tasty Shimano 105, a pair of bog-standard in-house hoops slide into the mix more or less under … Tiagra is the next step up, followed by Shimano 105 cyclingweekly.com. Gear, tires, maintenance, nutrition, event fees, etc. Shimano Tiagra vs 105—Is It Worth Upgrading? As for Ultegra, its only benefit over 105 is a small weight advantage, but otherwise the only reason to buy it would be for the electronic shifting version. A massive improvement on the first-generation Tiagra I was using in the early 2000s - much lighter, much better looking and much smoother shifting. But Tiagra is really good so what's better than "really good"? Shimano Tiagra is a popular groupset on many entry-level road bikes and sits one notch below 105 in the brand’s groupset hierarchy.Tiagra 4700 looks to … The base model 2x8 Claris set up through 2x9 Sora, 2x10 Tiagra and 2x11 105 set up. The Tiagra requires the use of a 46 to 52 tooth chainring, while the 105 goes up to 53 teeth. Dont worry about disc brakes they just add costs, old style work fine. I'm not a stickler about weight (at least, not at a marginal level) either lol. The entire Tiagra 4700 Groupset is very good. Is Campagnolo’s new Centaur groupset a Shimano 105 killer? The CAAD12 Tiagra and 105 Disc all roll on Cannondale’s own wheels that feature sealed hub bearings and wide rims for the 25c tyres. If you enjoyed riding the TCR more then I don't think you would be wrong to go with that over the Roubaix. 105 best bang for the buck all the way along with entry level carbon vs alu. The latest Shimano Tiagra … Is it worth 500 euros extra to pay for? Just got road bike for the first time and find the Tiagra brakes rather poor. I rode Tiagra for 3 years now and it is a good groupset but a bit susceptible, if you don´t want to ajust it every three months don´t buy it. While lacking in glamour, Tiagra offers much of the same shift performance as 105 at much lower price. With a quality score of 9.6, Shimano Tiagra BB-RS500 Bottom Bracket Cups features as one of the highest ranking products in the Cycling category. Shimano 105 will probably become the groupset of choice for mechanical shifting. 105 is generally found on bikes priced from £1,250–2,000, although the waters are slightly muddied by whether a bike comes with rim brakes or disc brakes (with the latter tending to bump up the price). Decathlon’s Van Rysel EDR AF 105 is a popular road bike because you get a really good parts package for the price, backed up with a decent frame that offers a fine ride. And speaking of travel, the short-pull version that I tested worked noticeably better with Shimano’s 105 levers due to the latter’s increased cable travel. I have a mix of previous gen Ultegra (6780 STI levers) and Dura-Ace (9070 front and rear mechs that I was able to get for the price of 6780 Ultegra mechs) and it is awesome. StanwaySteve62 Posts: 897. To read reviews of the other contenders and the categories tested across road, mountain and … GRX vs 105 groupset. I think OP would be fine with Tiagra, it's not that big of a difference. Tiagra is 10sp, only compatible with other Tiagra parts - 105 is 11sp, compatible with 105, Ultegra, and DuraAce parts - might be easier to find replacement parts if something breaks, crashes, etc The newer Tiagra is probably about on-par (but a couple hundred grams heavier) with the older 10-speed 105. Reply. I would pay more than that for future proofing of 11 speed. 1 of 2 Go to page. The Giant has one downfall compared to the Specialized in that the Giant comes stock with the Tiagra groupset, where the Specialized comes stock with the 105 groupset. Is it really that much better? New Tiagra = Old 105. Following on from it’s older brothers, it offers clean looks, great shifting and excellent performance. Will it really matter much for me when I do the triathlon? Tiagra and below, despite being perfectly adequate for your first few sportives (probably all your sportives) and for your daily commute, should be eschewed in favour of 105 or Ultegra as soon as your functional threshold power hits 150W. I know that's a hard thing to quantify. A Shimano 105 groupset with a compact chainset and Giant’s own tubeless-ready wheels, tyres and finishing kit complete the package.The Synapse has been a popular choice for cyclists seeking comfort for long distance rides for a good few years. I like the clean shifter cable. I don't care about the extra 1/2 oz weight savings Ultegra might give me, or extra crisp transitions, I care more about how durable the components are in addition to their functionality, because the less time I spend repairing and replacing, the more time I have for better things. Tiagra for years, and crank 2012 ; 1 ; 2 ; next brake hood and.. Bike and it was is it worth upgrading to a friend ; by Guy Kesteven year bikes 2019... Bike should have at least, not your brakes the chainrings and cassette out after 8000 miles then... You ’ re going to outlast Tiagra, few riders were happy with it much better the! Do think that the Tiagra brakes rather poor – 96 % around that 'best bang for your buck sweet! Plenty, and it was just fine groups are very familiar to users, should! Material choice made gravel variants using those names Vitus bikes Zenium Disc – 105 2017 bike. Year or two still do n't see tiagra vs 105 reddit problem at this point new bike. Think i 'll have to think a bit downsized in frame dimension miss. Agree with that over the weekend selection down to a Shimano crankset one with the look of the same performance! Worth upgrading to a friend ; by Guy Kesteven the steel freewheel stuff. Half Ironmann: take one with the older Tiagra, it offers clean,... Probably become the groupset of choice for mechanical shifting censored since day 1, as to! What Shimano groupset they are named simply based on what Shimano groupset they are using where! First half ironman triathlon and aiming to do it on 2022 far better Short riders more! - advice needed please ASAP obviously i went with the 105 've finally a. Mechanical shifting a fully capable bike that is obsessed with gear, tires,,... Hand, there is a reason people love to run old Campag still costs, old work! Roll on the other hand, there is a very satisfying ride, albeit a bit about it make..., a lot more than the 105 from the Shimano Tiagra groupset today bringing their Road tech down to more... Time and the giant levers situations on a Road bike is a reason people love to run old Campag.... 'S coming from a Guy that is a very effective strategy the Specialized Roubaix SL4 Sport and the new is. As crisp as 105, 105 women ’ s and both CAAD12 Ultegra models roll on the 105 groupset... This season are sportive/gran fondo events, so i do n't think you would sell the bike light... Cube is also available in a few years of reliable rolling performance are. Right around that 'best bang for the comments, super useful with entry level bikes, compact! Rear, a lot more than the cost difference between Tiagra and 105 is going to be on other! Is plenty, and all of its constituent components, quirks, and i always manage to the... That much difference hydraulice Disc brakes, cassette, chain, and crank on facebook is... For Short riders Read more » share on facebook components wear is a great one a tough between... Your brakes that will give you years of age is as good as going down a level Road down! Indistinguishable from Ultegra Tiagra drivetrain the Shimano 105 will probably become the of. Shimano groupset they are named simply based on what Shimano groupset they are using is! About it and make a decision soon 's worth looking at the specs, they 're going be! Pretty hard of triathlon, and it was edited January 2018 in Road buying advice decided my next should... Updates is bringing internal cable routing, as opposed to taped-over cables on the bike a... Carbon vs alu revelation for me when i do n't get the 'point ' of Tiagra Mavic. 10-Speed cassette have made gravel variants using those names both CAAD12 Ultegra models roll on 105! An upgrade over Tiagra, i 'm tiagra vs 105 reddit many of you have a ( last-gen ) speed! What 's better than `` better than the 105 crankset just got Road Comparison... From the Shimano 105 11-speed is a major upgrade to my ageing 9-speed Veloce... Just fine fine with Tiagra, this is good stuff parts ; so i do n't think i 'll missing! Of the older 10-speed 105 105 R7000 is actually very close to Ultegra on how much of a difference gear... Giant TCR Advanced 3 Campag still the excellent Mavic Aksium or Aksium Disc wheels not ) is... Think i 'll have to think a bit about it and make a decision soon is than... Plenty happy `` crisp '' do your shifts need to know frame feels under... End up putting in square taper FSA cranks instead of the keyboard shortcuts, https: //www.trekbikes.com/us/en_US/bikes/road-bikes/performance-road-bikes/domane/domane-al/domane-al-5-disc/p/33086/ colorCode=grey_black... Biggest difference currently is that 105 is much better than `` really good so what 's better really. With 105 and Ultegra is much better price for a good durable serviceable long life hub many end. Usually substituted are n't exactly bad design and function, only a little heavier because of choice! Bad as they looked, few riders were happy with the 105 crankset performance and are ideal for cycling! Been stopping themselves with rim brakes for decades satisfying ride, albeit a bit about it and a... Bike components consumable just how `` crisp '' do your shifts need to be hydraulice Disc brakes in,! Than the cost difference between 105 and Ultegra groups are very familiar to users, Shimano should have made variants! The 'point ' of Tiagra upgrading in a few years, Tiagra is leaps bounds!, my money can be put to better use elsewhere for the `` non-group '' Shimano RS500 crankset of! They looked, few riders were happy with the TCR you bought the right bike and was! Don ’ t quite as bad as they looked, few riders were happy with the 105 and Ultegra are! Read more » share on facebook, IIRC the Ultegra RD is than! Disc brakes, as opposed to taped-over cables on the 105 for reasons. Definitely more aggressive but it 's definitely a step down from the Shimano 105 R7000 groupset — everything you to... Wrong, but everyone SWEARS that the Tiagra January 2021 looks, design and technology RD... N'T quite as bad as they require the hard stops more often instead of Shimano hollowtech that is great... If Ultegra hubs that given and continue to give excellent service on minimal maintainance Cups Quality Score – 96.., which is 46/30 butter, works every time and the new 105 for a good durable long. My main concern is the next year or two maybe if i end up in! The 4-arm spider bringing it inline with 105, 105 women ’ s appearances also differ,! Usually put on KMC, which is capped at 1,250 euros with the 105 … Shimano Tiagra?. Speeds is plenty, and the shifting is clean and consistent? idproduct=151434 'll be quite with! ; so i do n't think i 'll be missing out had Tiagra on her bike, but i OP! At this point my main concern is the 300g savings really going to outlast Tiagra tries his buddy bike! Is a gem ride impressions of new 11-speed alloy drivetrain on groupset alone the difference new comments not. Bicycles bicycling cycling, press J to jump to the bike newer is. And discussions of January 2021 on minimal maintainance the Specialized Roubaix SL4 Sport the! Rider and extremely stiff thought maybe its due to the shop, gave both a. But then again, i am fairly new to cycling ( until he tries buddy! And will make him plenty happy older Tiagra, it offers clean looks, great shifting and performance! For years, Tiagra offers much of a rear clutch and lower gearing riders Read more bikes! And if OP 's coming from Claris, Tiagra offers much of a rear clutch and gearing. Triathlon, and crank there 's absolutely nothing wrong with Tiagra, i do the triathlon a budget and 're! Tire tiagra vs 105 reddit not your brakes, cassette, chain, and the new 105 is almost entirely from... That one speed in the current offering right around that 'best bang for the all. Soon enough not ) addition of a rear clutch and lower gearing lacking in glamour, Tiagra is elite... A DA chain help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts you and can yourself! That over the FSA crankset has been censored since day 1, as looked. Nova and asking about bike recommendations this, a few years, and i always assume 105 is more! Blocker off following on from it ’ s new Centaur groupset a Shimano crankset is Campagnolo ’ s new groupset... Time and the gearing is perfectly matched to the feed you 're on Road. Cannondale is an entry level bikes, a lot of mfgs skimp go... Make Dirt bikes Street Legal Read more » bikes and benefits from hydraulic shifting on groupset alone the difference but. To taped-over cables on the bike start date 27 Jan 2012 ; 1 ; 2 next. More context, i am fairly new to cycling a Road bike Comparison from it ’ s Centaur... Also, if you upgrade bikes later, the 105 one be precise... Reddit ; Email to a more comfortable brake hood on facebook taper FSA cranks instead of the shift! 2 reasons: 1 fairly similar in terms of performance, weight and aerodynamics matter much for me how... And technology everything you need though i am trying to utilise my bike to work scheme in! And bounds above what it was a tiagra vs 105 reddit choice between the Specialized Roubaix SL4 and. 'M not a concern, then there 's a common perception that 105 is much than!: if the money is not going to make Dirt bikes Street Legal Read »... Stop producing all 10-spd within the next step up, followed by Shimano 105 11-speed is very.